Every toy retailer wants to grow sales, but increasing prices isn't always the right answer. Parents are becoming more value-conscious, gift shoppers compare options carefully, and competition is only a click away. Fortunately, growing revenue doesn't always require charging customers more; it often means helping them buy smarter.
One of the most effective ways to strengthen toy store sales is to increase average order value (AOV). In simple terms, this means encouraging customers to purchase complementary products during a single visit rather than relying solely on attracting more shoppers.
The best part? When done thoughtfully, customers benefit too. A parent shopping for a building block set may genuinely appreciate a recommendation for a compatible storage box or an activity guide. A family buying a board game may enjoy discovering an expansion pack that adds even more fun to game night.
Successful toy retail strategies focus on creating better shopping experiences rather than pushing unnecessary purchases. By understanding customer needs and presenting relevant suggestions, retailers can improve satisfaction while supporting sustainable business growth.
In this guide, we'll explore practical ways to increase average order value, effective techniques for cross-selling toys, and proven strategies that help drive consistent toy store growth, all without raising prices.
A good pairing feels like helpful advice, not a sales pitch.
Why Average Order Value Matters More Than Discounting
Many retailers believe sales growth depends on running frequent promotions. While discounts may attract customers, they can also reduce profit margins and encourage shoppers to wait for the next sale. McKinsey's well-known pricing analysis found that, for a typical company, a 1% cut in average prices reduces operating profit by about 8% if sales volume stays the same.
Increasing average order value offers a more sustainable alternative. Instead of asking customers to spend more on one product, retailers help them discover additional items that naturally complement their purchase. For example:
- A 3D jigsaw puzzle paired with a puzzle mat
- A science kit combined with safety goggles
- A doll purchased alongside extra outfits
- An art set matched with sketchbooks
These combinations improve the customer's overall experience while increasing the value of each transaction. Even small increases in average order value can have a significant impact when repeated across hundreds or thousands of purchases throughout the year.
The quick math: average order value is total sales divided by the number of transactions. A store that takes in $18,000 across 600 transactions in a month has an AOV of $30. If one in five of those customers adds a $5 accessory, AOV rises to $31. That is $600 more revenue in the month without changing a single price tag.
Toy Retail Strategies That Encourage Higher Spending Naturally
The most successful retailers rarely pressure customers into buying more. Instead, they make shopping easier by presenting thoughtful recommendations at the right moment. Here are several proven toy retail strategies that encourage larger purchases while maintaining customer trust.
Organize Products by Play Experience
Rather than arranging products only by category, create displays that show how different toys work together. For example:
- A creative corner featuring art supplies, colouring books, craft kits, and scented dough sets
- A STEM section combining robotics kits, coding games, and science experiments
- A family game collection with board games suitable for different age groups
Customers often purchase complete experiences rather than individual products.
Offer Ready-Made Gift Bundles
Gift shopping becomes much easier when retailers curate thoughtful combinations. Bundles may include:
- An educational toy plus an activity book
- A building set with a storage solution
- An outdoor game with accessories
Convenience often encourages higher-value purchases while simplifying buying decisions.
Highlight Bestsellers
Customers frequently look for reassurance before making purchasing decisions. Featuring popular products with complementary recommendations helps build confidence while naturally introducing additional items. Sometimes shoppers simply need someone to say, "Other families love this combination too."
That kind of social proof is powerful. Research from Northwestern University's Spiegel Research Center found that a product with five online reviews is 270% more likely to be purchased than one with none. In store, a staff picks shelf built around best-selling toys and games does a similar job.
Cross-Selling Toys Without Feeling Pushy
Cross-selling toys works best when recommendations genuinely add value. Customers are far more likely to purchase additional products when they solve a practical need rather than feeling like a sales tactic. Effective cross-selling ideas include:
Recommend Accessories
Suggest batteries for electronic toys, protective cases for learning tablets, or storage containers for construction sets. Small, giftable add-ons work well near the checkout too; a counter display of collectible squishies gives shoppers an easy last-minute extra.
Pair Learning Products
An educational globe can be complemented with geography quiz cards or children's atlases.
Extend Play Value
Recommend expansion packs, refill kits, or additional character sets that encourage continued engagement. With board games making a big comeback in family entertainment, add-ons for popular titles are an easy recommendation.
Think About Age Progression
Parents often appreciate recommendations for products their child can enjoy as they continue developing new skills. Grouping stock by stage, such as 5 and under, 6 to 9 years, and 10 to 12 years, makes the next step easy to show.
The goal isn't to increase the basket at any cost. It's to make sure customers leave with everything they need for a better experience.
Building Trust Through Better Shopping Experiences
Long-term toy store growth depends on more than individual transactions. Customers return to stores where they feel understood, receive useful recommendations, and enjoy a pleasant shopping experience. That personal touch is also how independent toy stores compete with big-box retailers.
When retailers focus on solving customer needs rather than simply increasing sales, larger purchases become a natural outcome. Thoughtful merchandising, relevant product pairings, and knowledgeable staff create an environment where shoppers feel confident spending more because every recommendation genuinely adds value.
Good, better, best: a tiered shelf lets families compare value at a glance.
Retail Upselling That Customers Actually Appreciate
The word "upselling" sometimes gets an unfair reputation. Many people imagine an aggressive sales pitch that leaves customers feeling pressured. In reality, good retail upselling is simply about helping shoppers discover a better solution.
Instead of encouraging customers to spend more for the sake of it, focus on enhancing the value of their purchase. Here are a few customer-friendly approaches.
Present Better Alternatives
If a customer is comparing two similar products, explain the practical differences rather than simply recommending the more expensive option. For example, a premium building set may include more pieces, higher durability, or additional learning opportunities. When customers understand the value, they're more comfortable making informed decisions.
Create Tiered Product Displays
Displaying products in entry-level, mid-range, and premium categories helps shoppers compare options more confidently. Rather than overwhelming customers with endless choices, this structure makes decision-making easier. A games wall, for example, might step up from quick card games to family board games to a premium tabletop soccer game.
Encourage Seasonal Purchases
Festive periods, birthdays, school holidays, and special occasions provide natural opportunities to recommend products that complement the customer's original purchase.
Reward Larger Purchases
Instead of offering discounts, consider value-added incentives such as:
- Complimentary gift wrapping above a purchase threshold
- Loyalty points
- Small educational freebies
- Exclusive member benefits
Customers enjoy receiving additional value without feeling pressured into spending more.
Long-Term Strategies for Sustainable Toy Store Growth
Increasing today's sales is important, but building lasting customer relationships creates stronger business growth over time. Retailers that consistently deliver excellent service, thoughtful product recommendations, and engaging shopping experiences often see repeat visits and positive word-of-mouth referrals. Consider these long-term toy store growth strategies.
Build Customer Loyalty
Loyal customers often spend more over time than first-time visitors. Simple loyalty programs, birthday rewards, or exclusive previews of new arrivals encourage repeat purchases. The payoff can be significant: research by Frederick Reichheld of Bain & Company, highlighted by Harvard Business Review, found that raising customer retention by 5% can increase profits by 25% to 95%.
Use Customer Purchase History
Understanding previous purchases allows retailers to recommend products that genuinely match customer interests. For example, a family that regularly purchases STEM toys may appreciate updates about newly launched science kits. Shoppers expect this attention: McKinsey's research on personalization found that 71% of consumers expect personalized interactions, and 76% get frustrated when that doesn't happen.
Refresh Product Displays Regularly
Returning customers are more likely to explore the store when displays change frequently. Rotating featured products also increases visibility for items that might otherwise go unnoticed. Keeping an eye on the toy industry trends retailers should watch in 2026 helps decide what earns the front table next.
Train Staff Continuously
Knowledgeable employees remain one of the most valuable assets in retail. When staff understand child development, product features, and age-appropriate recommendations, customers are more likely to trust their suggestions.
Useful training topics include Health Canada's safety requirements for children's toys, including labelling rules, and the developmental benefits of play, such as how puzzles build problem-solving skills. After all, people often remember helpful advice long after they've forgotten the price tag.
Measuring What Works
Every strategy should be supported by data. Tracking a few key performance indicators helps retailers understand which initiatives are delivering results. Useful metrics include:
- Average order value
- Items purchased per transaction
- Repeat customer rate
- Bundle sales performance
- Conversion rate of product recommendations
Reviewing these figures regularly allows store owners to refine merchandising, staff training, and promotional activities for even better results. Small improvements measured consistently often produce significant long-term growth.
Conclusion
Growing a successful toy business isn't always about attracting more customers or increasing prices. Often, the greatest opportunity lies in helping existing customers discover products that add genuine value to their purchase.
By focusing on thoughtful toy retail strategies, increasing average order value through relevant recommendations, and cross-selling toys with a customer-first mindset, retailers can strengthen both profitability and customer satisfaction. Every interaction becomes an opportunity to create a more enjoyable shopping experience rather than simply another transaction.
Over time, these small, consistent improvements contribute to meaningful toy store growth. Customers return because they trust the recommendations, appreciate the service, and enjoy finding products that bring lasting value to their families. In the world of toy retail, that combination is worth far more than a temporary discount.
Stock the add-ons that grow every basket
1Di supplies retailers across Canada with toys, games, puzzles, and gifts from Prime 3D, Kess, Binho, RMS, and more. Register for a wholesale account to unlock wholesale pricing.
Register for wholesale Browse the product catalogue